Sprained vs Broken Ankle: Understanding the Difference

November 14, 2023

The ankle is a complex and crucial joint in the human body, responsible for providing stability and facilitating movement. Unfortunately, ankle injuries are fairly common, with sprains and fractures being among the most prevalent. While both may result from similar traumatic incidents, it is important to understand the key differences between a sprained ankle and a broken ankle in order to receive appropriate treatment and achieve a successful recovery.

Anatomy of the Ankle

Before diving into the specifics of ankle sprains and fractures, it is essential to grasp the anatomy of this intricate joint. The ankle is formed by three bones: the tibia, fibula, and talus. These bones are connected by strong ligaments, allowing for stability and flexibility. Additionally, the ankle is supported and protected by tendons, muscles, and a network of blood vessels and nerves.

Key Components of the Ankle

The tibia, commonly known as the shinbone, is the main weight-bearing bone in the lower leg. It sits on the inside of the ankle, forming the medial malleolus. In contrast, the fibula resides on the outer side of the leg and contributes to the formation of the lateral malleolus. These two bones provide stability and support to the ankle joint. The talus, encompassed by the tibia and fibula, connects the ankle to the foot, enabling essential movements such as dorsiflexion and plantarflexion.

How the Ankle Functions

The ankle joint operates through a combination of intricate movements, predominantly acting as a hinge joint. It allows for dorsiflexion, the motion of bringing the toes upward towards the shin, and plantarflexion, the motion of pointing the toes downward away from the shin. These actions allow us to walk, run, jump, and effectively navigate various terrains.

What is a Sprained Ankle?

A sprained ankle occurs when the ligaments that connect the bones in the ankle joint are stretched or torn. This often happens when the ankle is twisted or turned beyond its normal range of motion. Sprains are commonly caused by activities that involve sudden changes in direction or landing improperly after a jump.

Causes of Ankle Sprains

Ankle sprains can result from a variety of situations, such as sports injuries, tripping, falling, or stepping on uneven surfaces. High-impact activities like basketball, soccer, and trail running often carry a higher risk of ankle sprains due to the quick pivoting and cutting movements involved.

Symptoms and Diagnosis of Ankle Sprains

When an ankle is sprained, symptoms may include pain, swelling, bruising, and difficulty walking or bearing weight on the affected foot. To diagnose an ankle sprain, a healthcare professional will typically perform a physical examination, assessing the range of motion, stability, and tenderness of the ankle. In some cases, imaging tests such as X-rays or MRI scans may be ordered to rule out the possibility of a fracture or assess the severity of the sprain.

Treatment and Recovery from Ankle Sprains

The initial treatment for ankle sprains typically involves the RICE method: rest, ice, compression, and elevation. Resting the affected ankle and avoiding weight-bearing activities allows the ligaments to heal. Applying ice packs and compression bandages help reduce swelling and inflammation. Elevating the foot above heart level also aids in reducing swelling. Additionally, physical therapy exercises, such as range-of-motion exercises and strengthening exercises, may be recommended to restore strength and stability to the ankle.

What is a Broken Ankle?

A broken ankle, also known as an ankle fracture, occurs when one or more of the bones in the ankle joint break. Fractures can range from minor cracks or hairline fractures to more severe breaks that involve displacement of the bones. Ankle fractures can happen as a result of direct trauma, such as a fall or a sports-related injury, or occur due to underlying conditions such as osteoporosis.

Causes of Ankle Fractures

Common causes of ankle fractures include falls from heights, twisting forces applied to the ankle, significant impacts during sports activities, and accidents involving motor vehicles. Weakened bones due to conditions like osteoporosis can also contribute to the likelihood of sustaining an ankle fracture.

Symptoms and Diagnosis of Ankle Fractures

If an ankle is broken, symptoms may include severe pain, swelling, bruising, visible deformity, and an inability to bear weight on the affected leg. To diagnose an ankle fracture, a healthcare professional will typically conduct a physical examination and order imaging tests such as X-rays or CT scans to determine the exact location and severity of the fracture.

Treatment and Recovery from Ankle Fractures

The course of treatment for an ankle fracture depends on the specific type and location of the break. In some cases, a cast or splint may be sufficient for immobilizing the ankle and allowing the bones to heal. However, more severe fractures may require surgical intervention to realign the bones and stabilize the ankle with screws, plates, or other devices. Following treatment, rehabilitation and physical therapy play a crucial role in restoring mobility, strength, and function to the ankle.

Comparing Sprained and Broken Ankles

While both sprained and broken ankles can result in pain, swelling, and limited mobility, there are several distinct differences between the two injuries that should be understood.

Similarities Between Sprains and Fractures

Both sprained and broken ankles can occur due to sudden trauma, such as a fall or a misstep, and both may require varying degrees of rest and rehabilitation to achieve a full recovery. Additionally, the initial symptoms of pain, swelling, and difficulty walking may be similar for both injuries.

Key Differences in Symptoms

One key difference between a sprained ankle and a broken ankle is the presence of visible deformity. An ankle fracture often causes a noticeable misalignment or a protrusion of bone, while a sprained ankle generally does not result in visible structural changes. X-rays or other imaging tests are necessary to confirm the presence of a fracture.

Differences in Treatment and Recovery

The treatment and recovery process for sprained and broken ankles differ based on the severity of the injury. Ankle sprains typically heal with conservative measures, such as rest, ice, compression, and elevation, followed by physical therapy. On the other hand, ankle fractures may require casting, splinting, or surgical intervention to realign and stabilize the bones. Rehabilitation for fracture patients is often longer and may include exercises to regain strength and mobility.

In conclusion, understanding the difference between a sprained ankle and a broken ankle is crucial in determining the appropriate course of action for treatment and recovery. While sprains involve stretched or torn ligaments, fractures entail broken bones within the ankle joint. By recognizing the unique symptoms and utilizing diagnostic tools, healthcare professionals can provide optimal care to individuals suffering from these common ankle injuries. Prompt and accurate treatment, coupled with comprehensive rehabilitation, will aid in restoring function and enabling individuals to resume their daily activities with confidence.


Ready Fit Physiotherapy

You May Also Like

Discussion – 


Discussion – 



Get in Touch

(+65) 8800 2351



Email us

General Enquiries
Helpdesk/Customer Service
Business & other related matters 

23 Binjai Park, Singapore 589828
6 Raffles Blvd, Marina Square #03-137 Singapore 039594

× WhatsApp